Up until 2015, the indigent defense system in Michigan was nothing short of a disaster.
The entire state—83 counties—had only five staffed public defender offices. Judges sometimes appointed their political donors to take cases, then encouraged them to have their clients plead guilty, often without even hearing the defendant’s side.
Perhaps most tellingly, funding for indigent defense was among the lowest in the country. Cases often went to the lawyer offering the lowest bid for services—which only exacerbated problems of low pay and overwork for the people providing the services.
It was a mess, and none of it was a secret. However, a series of reforms enacted over the last 10 to 12 years has caused conditions to improve dramatically—and the Michigan Law community has played a critical role in that progress.
Pre-2015 Michigan
5 of 83
counties had staffed public defender offices
A broken system of public defense
Michigan had never really lived up to the Sixth Amendment promise of a right to counsel for indigent defendants, reinforced by the US Supreme Court in 1963’s Gideon v. Wainwright.
Although Michigan had been one of the first states to require the appointment of paid counsel, in 1857, that responsibility fell to individual counties. The Michigan system, such as it was, left each county to figure out public defense on its own—leading to an unreliable patchwork of poorly funded, poorly run setups.
Around 25 years ago, reform efforts slowly started to build. A state task force created by the Michigan Council on Crime and Delinquency convened in 2001, and a group called the Campaign for Justice started advocating for reforms—without much success, at least initially.
Then two developments kick-started the process.
In 2006, the state legislature authorized a major study of Michigan’s system of public defense. The report—titled a “A Race to the Bottom” and released in 2008 by the National Legal Aid and Defender Association—found that Michigan’s per-capita spending on indigent defense ranked 44th out of the 50 states (and was 38 percent less than the national average).
The report’s executive summary laid out the problems: “judges handpicking defense attorneys; lawyers appointed to cases for which they are unqualified; defenders meeting clients on the eve of trial and holding non-confidential discussions in public courtroom corridors; attorneys failing to identify obvious conflicts of interest; failure of defenders to properly prepare for trials or sentencings; attorneys violating their ethical canons to zealously advocate for clients; inadequate compensation for those appointed to defend the accused; and a lack of sufficient time, training, investigators, experts, and resources to properly prepare a case in the face of a state court system that values the speed with which cases are disposed of over the needs of clients for competent representation.”
While that report was still being prepared, in 2007 the ACLU of Michigan sued the state in Duncan v. Michigan, seeking to reform the state’s indigent defense system.
Professor from Practice Michael Steinberg, now director of the Civil Rights Litigation Initiative at the Law School, was working as the legal director of the state ACLU when the group decided to file its suit.
“It was clear that the Michigan indigent defense system was completely broken. For a year and a half, we tried to figure out a way to bring an impact case that would reform the system and draw attention to the problem,” Steinberg says.
“We adopted a true integrated-advocacy approach. While the Campaign for Justice was working with the lawmakers and developing grassroots support for legislative reform, we applied pressure on the state through a lawsuit.”
Building the lawsuit took a long time. The team—which included the national ACLU; the Brennan Center for Justice; and lawyers from Cravath, Swaine & Moore in New York—researched which counties to focus on, ultimately choosing Genesee, Muskegon, and Berrien. They watched how the courts treated indigent defendants and collected individual defendants’ stories.
The state filed a motion to dismiss the case, but the ACLU won at the trial level, at the Court of Appeals, and finally at the Michigan Supreme Court. The case went through an initial Supreme Court ruling in favor of the plaintiffs, then a reversal, and finally a reversal of the reversal. “It was unheard of,” Steinberg says.
The case went back to the trial court. Yet before it got much further, the state government—driven by the lawsuit and the “Race to the Bottom” report—finally acted on the issue, which was the ultimate goal all along. The ACLU dismissed its case.
In 2011, the state created an indigent defense advisory commission appointed by Gov. Rick Snyder, ’82. Ann Arbor attorney John Shea, ’82, who had been part of the Campaign for Justice, also served on the advisory commission.
“Snyder had said, ‘Let’s take control. It’s a problem, and we should figure it out,’” Shea recalls. The advisory commission developed a proposed legislative package—which the legislature approved, mostly intact and with bipartisan support, in 2013.
That law created the permanent Michigan Indigent Defense Commission (MIDC) as well as a statewide funding structure for the new system. Finally, the machinery was in place for real change.
Major changes make a difference
Shea was appointed to the MIDC in 2016, as the group worked to roll out a series of statewide standards for indigent defense that each county could figure out how to meet. The standards took the American Bar Association’s principles for public defense as a starting point but adapted them to Michigan’s unique needs.
“We identified what the standards should be, and then we identified in what order we wanted to roll them out,” Shea says. “We knew we couldn’t hit the legislature with a choking amount of funding. If we started with better pay or caseload limits, there would have been a big price tag. So we started with training standards.”
Fiscal years 2019 to 2027
$82M-$211M
Growing funding from the state as new standards have been introduced
As the commission introduced each standard, individual counties proposed their compliance plans. Once the commission approved the plans—sometimes after substantial revisions—they were included in funding requests to the state.
“Then we started rolling out other standards, like judicial independence,” Shea says. “The judges shouldn’t be picking the lawyers. There has to be an independent way of assigning the lawyers. Otherwise, the system gets corrupted.”
The first four indigent defense standards were approved in 2017; since then, five more have been added. They cover things like training and education, use of investigation and experts, independence from the judiciary, qualification and review of attorneys in adult criminal cases, and attorney compensation.
MIDC Executive Director Kristen Staley says before the state introduced standards, only one court in the state—Ingham County District Court in Mason, near Lansing—had counsel present at arraignments. A mandate for counsel to be present started in 2019, and by 2021, all courts were compliant.
The newest standard—caseload limits of 150 felonies and 400 misdemeanors a year—went into effect in 2025. Compliance efforts have received growing funding from the state as new standards have been introduced: from $82 million in FY19 to $211 million for the coming year.
Along the way, the number of full-time public defender offices in the state has grown from five to more than 30. “The counties have become professional,” Shea says. “They’ve hired professional people to put these compliance plans together and administer the programs. The system really is reformed. It’s not perfect by any means, but it is significantly better.”
Those who work in the system have seen the results.
Shea notes that the vast majority of criminal cases, around 95 percent, end up in a plea deal. “If you are a lousy plea advocate and sentencing advocate, people are getting over-convicted and over-punished. If you’re a good plea advocate and sentencing advocate, clients are getting convicted of things that are more fair and getting sentences that are more fair,” he says.
Since the State of Michigan implemented its reforms, “in many cases, average sentences are down, and that’s a direct result of better sentencing advocacy and better deal cutting,” he says. “Done properly, over time, that can cover the cost of an indigent defense system, because the state saves money on corrections costs.
“There are also human outcomes. Having counsel at first appearance can get people out on bond, when previously they would've been lodged—and lost their job, maybe gotten evicted, maybe had a problem with Child Protective Services because they're living out of their car. Those human outcomes are real.”
Tracey Brame, ’95, was appointed to the MIDC in 2019 and later reappointed. In January 2026, Brame—who also serves as associate dean of experiential learning and practice preparation at Cooley Law School—assumed the role of MIDC chairperson.
She has seen the results firsthand—“cases being dismissed, trials being won, client satisfaction being greater”—since the state implemented its reforms.
“But also, attorney satisfaction has improved,” she says. “Attorneys feel as though they can make a decent living doing this work, instead of doing it for a couple of years and then saying, ‘There's just no way I can continue to do this.’ You get better representation and more longevity. ”
The path to reform
- 1857
Michigan requires the appointment of paid counsel
- 1963
US Supreme Court decides Gideon v. Wainwright
- 2001
State task force convenes; Campaign for Justice starts advocating for reform
- 2006
State legislature authorizes a major study of Michigan’s system of public defense
- 2007
ACLU of Michigan sues the state in Duncan v. Michigan
- 2008
Michigan’s per-capita spending on indigent defense ranks 44th out of the 50 states
- 2011
State creates an indigent defense advisory commission
- 2013
Advisory commission develops a proposed legislative package that includes establishing the Michigan Indigent Defense Commission (MIDC)
- 2016
MIDC works to roll out a series of statewide standards for indigent defense that each county can figure out how to meet
- 2017
First four indigent defense standards are approved
- 2019
A mandate for counsel to be present at arraignments is added
- 2025
New caseload limits of 150 felonies and 400 misdemeanors a year go into effect
- 2026
Legislation expands the MIDC’s purview to include indigent juvenile defense
Extending the reach of reforms
With the core standards now in place, the MIDC’s work has shifted focus. MIDC staff handle more than 100 proposals each year for programs that counties want to fund, and the commission has final say in those grants.
“Much of our work now focuses on the local systems around the state,” Brame says. “We funnel resources to local systems to help them meet the standards.”
The MIDC also coordinates with local systems on providing continuing legal education for indigent defense, which is now an annual requirement, Brame adds. Commissioners also discuss any problems that may arise in the system.
The biggest looming issue involves juvenile justice. In July 2026, Gov. Gretchen Whitmer signed legislation expanding the MIDC’s purview to include indigent juvenile defense.
“Now we’re going to do the same thing for juveniles in trial court that we’ve done for adults,” Brame says. “We’re going to implement standards. We’re going to monitor the adherence to those standards. We’re going to have a budget.
“I don’t yet know just what that’s going to look like, but it’s super exciting. It’s something that we’ve been working toward for the last couple of years, because we have the same issues at the juvenile level as at the adult level—resources and continuity and consistency. Now we get to work on that.”
Mira Edmonds, clinical professor of law and director of the Juvenile Justice Clinic, welcomes the new development. “It’s overdue,” she says. The MIDC has expressed interest in working with the clinic on developing the new standards.
Better funding will also be critical, Edmonds adds. Currently, juvenile defenders in many counties are paid only $125 per court appearance.
“There’s simply no way that a person can adequately represent a youth at that pay scale. The lawyers literally can’t afford to spend more than an hour prepping for those appearances, and that is not really providing competent legal counsel,” she says.
The Juvenile Justice Clinic is in the midst of a pilot program, funded by a state grant, that could inform the MIDC’s work on juvenile defense. Under the program, a social worker gives support to clinic students, clients, and families and also provides training, consultations, and referrals to juvenile defenders around the state. The clinic is just starting to gather data to gauge its effectiveness.
“We are hoping that one of the things that this project will demonstrate is that particularly for kids, you really can’t solve the problem that involvement with the delinquency system represents without looking at the root causes—such as neglect and abuse, entrenched poverty, mental health challenges, and inadequate educational opportunities,” Edmonds says. “I’m hoping that we’ll be able to produce data that will show how much of a positive impact a social worker integrated as part of the defense team can make on the quality of representation.”
Making Michigan a model
Even as the commission begins to work on the juvenile defense system, other big topics remain to be addressed. Some in the system are seeking lower caseload standards. Funding will likely remain a concern, given the unpredictable nature of politics and the state budget process.
“The Michigan Legislature has been fantastic about making sure that we have the funds that we need in order to make this happen,” Brame says. “Long term, I’d like to see us get to a point where our work is a given and we don’t have to justify it each year.”
Another issue is the varying quality of representation from one location to another.
“We have lawyer deserts in Michigan,” Shea says. “We have parts of Michigan where you don't have a vibrant defense bar. Getting coverage in parts of the northern Lower Peninsula and in parts of the Upper Peninsula is a real challenge.”
Eve Brensike Primus, ’01—the Yale Kamisar Collegiate Professor of Law, director of the MDefenders program, and director of the Public Defender Training Institute at Michigan Law—says that more public defenders are critical.
“It is still the case that the majority of people in Michigan who are accused of crimes and who don’t have the money to afford a lawyer are not going to get a full-time public defender,” she says. “There has been amazing growth in Michigan in the last 10 years, but we’re really just at the tip of the iceberg of where we need to go.”
Brame aims to expand the pipeline of attorneys by making Michigan “known as a destination for public defense,” she says. “I want law students around the country to think, ‘The MIDC has this system in Michigan, and we want to go practice criminal defense in Michigan because we know that they practice in excellence.’”
Primus notes that many states have a long way to go to get to a point where they are providing constitutionally effective representation. “Nationally, we have a crisis in indigent defense. We don’t have enough lawyers, and we’re killing the lawyers we do have with excessive caseloads,” Primus says.
“Many people around the country are looking to Michigan as an example of what to do to reform loosely organized, county-based indigent defense delivery systems that are in shambles. We've come a long way, and others look to Michigan now as a model.”