Across the United States, health care fraud is a profitable, if illicit, business. And no state does it quite like California.
“Big picture, there is a crisis in the United States,” says Derrelle Janey, ’96, an experienced trial lawyer who recently joined Olshan Frome Wolosky LLP as a partner. “Similar to a lot of crises, there are hot zones around the country. And California is the hottest hot zone.”
In part, that’s because California is the most populous state, but it also offers unusually broad eligibility when it comes to the state’s version of Medicaid. Meanwhile, new developments in the health care industry—specifically, telemedicine and the rise of third-party billing operations that can process claims in bulk—have made fraud even easier.
It’s a problem, and one that the federal government has a clear interest in combating. Indeed, enforcing laws against health care fraud is now a major priority for the US Department of Justice. But, as a recent case of Janey’s demonstrates, it’s important for both sides to know the rules.
A wellspring of qui tam actions
Lifschutz v. Ghasseminejad involved what’s known as a qui tam action, in which a private party brings a lawsuit on behalf of the government. In this case, a physician alleged that his patients had been fraudulently enrolled in hospice for the purposes of billing Medicaid. Under the federal False Claims Act, plaintiffs who bring qui tam actions can receive a share of any money recovered from people or companies that knowingly file false requests for payment to the government. In this case, that might have meant tens of millions of dollars.
With the government’s recent focus on health care fraud, Janey says, “qui tam is exploding, and an entire wellspring of plaintiffs’ lawyers has sprung up.” Janey worries that some of them don’t fully understand the burden of proof in fraud cases.
“How you draft the complaint becomes extremely important,” says Janey, who defended Kaysan Ghasseminejad, who oversees a network of home hospice companies. “This is the piece that can be easy to miss—and certainly what the lawyers representing the plaintiff in Lifschutz, in my opinion, missed. A claim under the False Claims Act is a fraud claim. Under Rule 8 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, you just need to give a general account of what occurred. But because you’re alleging fraud, Rule 9 applies.”
Rule 9 imposes heightened requirements for certain allegations. Specifically, in fraud cases, 9(b) states, “a party must state with particularity the circumstances constituting fraud or mistake.” That means offering what Janey calls “the newspaper account: the who, what, when, where, how” of the fraud, with great specificity.
Unfortunately for the Lifschutz plaintiff, his attorneys failed to meet that standard. A Central District of California judge cited Rule 9(b) and granted Janey’s motion to dismiss the case earlier this year.
“This is a highly experienced judge saying that the federal rules, particularly Rule 9, actually matter when you draft these complaints,” Janey says.
Derrelle Janey, ’96Working these cases can be a very physical, interactive, cerebral, cognitive exercise, and you can treat that intellectual process as building blocks over time, in the course of your career.
Staying the course
The rules of civil procedure are not exactly glamorous, he acknowledges. As a 1L at Michigan Law, he struggled to care about them himself—but Arthur R. Miller, his civil procedure professor, instilled in him that a deep understanding of the rules is critical to every persuasive argument.
It’s a basic truth that every attorney needs to learn, he says, and one that he now fully appreciates because of his experience working complex cases. One RICO case involving pharmaceutical companies twisted and turned for eight years, he remembers. And then there was the high-profile insider-trading case involving the multilevel marketing company Herbalife and the billionaire hedge fund manager Bill Ackman.
“Working these cases can be a very physical, interactive, cerebral, cognitive exercise, and you can treat that intellectual process as building blocks over time, in the course of your career,” he says. “When you’ve worked cases that big, that complicated, you can look at a complaint like Lifschutz and say, ‘They’re alleging fraud … and I don’t think the plaintiffs really know that they’re alleging fraud.’”